Quick Summary
Sony has lost a court case it brought to stop third-party firms from altering its games without express permission.
An EU court has found that Datel's cheat-inducing software for MotorStorm was operating legally.
A European court has ruled that game-changing software sold or distributed by a third-party does not infringe copyright. That effectively means that a game released on console or PC can legally be altered through cheat software and mods without the original copyright holder's permission.
The case was brought by PlayStation, which argued that UK firm Datel was breaching copyright rules when it marketed and sold software that adapted Sony's MotorStorm to add cheats, such as infinite boosts.
However, the European Court of Justice in Luxembourg ruled that games can be legally adapted temporarily.
"The directive on the legal protection of computer programs does not allow the holder of that protection to prohibit the marketing by a third party of software which merely changes variables transferred temporarily," it said in a statement (via EuroNews).
"The directive protects only the intellectual creation as it is reflected in the text of the computer program’s source code and object code."
As Datel's modifications don't alter the source code and only change "variables" running in the game's working memory, they have been ruled to be doing so within the law.
Sony's own take on it is that such software "latches on... like a parasite".
Sign up to the T3 newsletter for smarter living straight to your inbox
Get all the latest news, reviews, deals and buying guides on gorgeous tech, home and active products from the T3 experts
Of course, the argument is based on a game released many years ago on a long deceased console – the PlayStation 3. However, the ramifications of the ruling could be wide-reaching.
It effectively opens the door to other companies releasing their own cheat-code add-ons for PS5, Xbox Series X/S, Nintendo Switch and PC games – in the EU, at least. As long as they don't touch the source code, it seems it's all fair game.
Rik is T3’s news editor, which means he looks after the news team and the up-to-the-minute coverage of all the hottest gadgets and products you’ll definitely want to read about. And, with more than 35 years of experience in tech and entertainment journalism, including editing and writing for numerous websites, magazines, and newspapers, he’s always got an eye on the next big thing.
Rik also has extensive knowledge of AV, TV streaming and smart home kit, plus just about everything to do with games since the late 80s. Prior to T3, he spent 13 years at Pocket-lint heading up its news team, and was a TV producer and presenter on such shows as Channel 4's GamesMaster, plus Sky's Games World, Game Over, and Virtual World of Sport.
-
Xiaomi's new mini washer dryer has 20 different programmes – and it's only 18 inches tall
It's the ideal appliance for smaller living spaces
By Lizzie Wilmot Published
-
Free YouTube app update could help keep the kids quiet over the holidays
Save your sanity with the wonder of technology – thanks to YouTube
By Chris Hall Published
-
PSVR2 just got a game-changing update, but Sony’s keeping quiet about it
Hand tracking will change the way you play, but Sony's hardly mentioned it
By Carrie Marshall Published
-
Sony PS Vita 2 could snatch the handheld crown from Switch 2 and Steam Deck
Industry experts "confirm" Sony is working on an all-new handheld console
By Rik Henderson Published
-
All PS Plus members getting arguably the best PS5 co-op game ever for free
You just need the two of you
By Rik Henderson Last updated
-
Xbox gamers finally get the essential Cloud Gaming update they've been waiting for
You can now play your own Xbox games on any device
By Rik Henderson Published
-
I sold my PS5 to upgrade to the PS5 Pro and it might have been a mistake
Do I regret it? Ask me again in six months...
By Max Freeman-Mills Published
-
PlayStation Portal just got a game-changing free update
Turns it into one of the best gaming handhelds around
By Rik Henderson Published
-
Has the PlayStation Black Friday sale started yet?
The PlayStation Store's big Black Friday sale is now underway and includes consoles
By Rik Henderson Last updated
-
Xbox handheld confirmed along with "future Xbox consoles" – but there's a catch
Xbox boss Phil Spencer has revealed future hardware plans
By Rik Henderson Published