The results of a new study suggest that resistance exercise is better for improving your sleep compared to aerobic exercise. The study comes from the American Heart Association, and was prompted by the link between high-quality sleep and cardiovascular health, for which aerobic exercise is typically recommended.
The study (opens in new tab) lasted a full year and involved 386 adults, all with a BMI that falls into the obese or overweight range and who were inactive and suffered from high blood pressure. They were split into four groups: one group would participate in aerobic exercise for the year, another would do just resistance exercises, and another would do a combination of the two styles. A final control group did no exercise for the year. Those groups exercising participated in supervised 60-minute sessions, three times a week (scroll down for more info on the workouts).
At the start of the study, 42% of the participants were getting less than 7 hours of sleep a night. After a year, of that 42%, sleep duration increased by an average of 40 minutes in the resistance exercise group. There were increases in the other groups, too, but not as significant: the aerobic group reported an increase of about 23 minutes extra sleep, the combined group about 17 minutes and the control group about 15 minutes.
The study also looked at sleep efficiency – that is, how much time someone is actually asleep divided by the total amount of time they're in bed for. Here, the resistance exercise group again saw improvements, alongside the combined group, while the aerobic group and control group recorded no change. Sleep latency (how long it takes a person to drop off) decreased in the resistance group by three minutes, but there was no significant change in any other group.
The trend didn't quite continue across the board. For example, sleep quality and sleep disturbances (how often sleep is disturbed, by things like being too hot or too cold, snoring or coughing, having to go to the toilet, or bodily aches and pains) improved a bit in all groups, including the no-exercise control groups. The study is also slightly limited by the fact that sleep quality was self-reported, rather than being objectively measured using a sleep tracker. However, those results are still significant, especially as this is one of the largest and longest exercise trials in a general adult population to explore this topic.
"While both aerobic and resistance exercise are important for overall health, our results suggest that resistance exercises may be superior when it comes to getting better ZZZs at night," study author Angelique Brellenthin, assistant professor of kinesiology at Iowa State University, told ScienceDaily (opens in new tab). "Resistance exercise significantly improved sleep duration and sleep efficiency, which are critical indicators of sleep quality that reflects how well a person falls asleep and stays asleep throughout the night."
Her recommendation, if you've found your sleep quality has deteriorated, is to explore some resistance exercises: "Consider incorporating two or more resistance exercise training sessions into your regular exercise routine to improve your general muscle and bone health, as well as your sleep."
What kind of exercises could help you sleep?
So exactly what kinds of exercise yielded these results? The aerobic group could choose to work out on a treadmill, recumbent or upright exercise bike or elliptical trainer, and their heart rates were monitored to keep them in the range for moderate to vigorous-intensity exercise.
You're probably more interested in the resistance group though. Here's an example of the kind of workouts they took part in.
3 sets of 8 to 16 repetitions
- Leg press
- Chest press
- Lat pulldown
- Leg curl
- Leg extension
- Biceps curl
- Triceps pushdown
- Shoulder press
- Abdominal crunch
- Lower back extension
- Torso rotation
- Hip abduction
The study group maintained 50-80% of their one-rep maximum (essentially maximum effort – here's a quick 1RM explainer, if you need it) throughout the sessions. They used 12 different resistance machines for their workouts, but if you fancy seeing if this kind of exercise could help improve your sleep, too, most of these can be achieved at home, with a little bit of kit.
To get you started, try this easy full-body single dumbbell workout only or this 15-minute low-impact full-body workout. Both are excellent to tire out the entire body which is key to better sleep. We recommend doing these workouts in the morning or early afternoon as opposed to right before bed as exercising late might have an adverse effect on sleep quality (here's when you should stop exercising before bed).
