Want to know how to cook pizza at home? Many guides to making pizza at home will tell you it's incredibly complex. And some other ones go the other way and pretend it's overly simple. The truth, as is so often the case, lies somewhere in between.
Thankfully, T3's resident al fresco dining expert is here to supply the answers to your pizza-based questions. It's-a me! Derek-a Adams-a! I may be as authentically Italian as Wario from the Nintendo Switch games, but I do like a nice home-baked pizza. Just like momma didn't use to make.
Making pizza at home: the prep sequence
First you need one of the best pizza ovens, to place in your garden. Alternatively, if you have an indoor oven like the new Sage Pizzaiolo, set it up in the kitchen or outdoors if dry enough.
What you don't want to do is even consider using the kitchen oven because even the best oven is only going to hit 300ºC against a dedicated pizza oven's 400˚C-plus. Unless, of course, you want to experiment with using the pyrolytic cleaning setting to cook pizzas.
I'm kidding: do not under ANY circumstances do that.
Before I divulge all the good things about home-based pizza making, I should forewarn you that it’s quite an art and there’s a steep learning curve involved. Not with the actual baking – anyone can do that, with a decent pizza oven – but the preparation. Pizza making is also incredibly messy so I would advise wearing an apron or you'll look like you've been on the receiving end of a flour fight.
To make proper Italian restaurant-style pizza you'll need the right type of flour – Italian-type 00 is the one to go for – and some spring water or, for real authenticity, salted water – preferably from the Mediterranean. Okay, perhaps you don't live near a spring, or the Med, but you can use bottled water. Or at the very least water that's been through the best water filter jug. Seriously, do not use tap water. This is an offer you can't refuse.
The next step is the kneading process (strictly no rolling pins here guys, so prepare to dig those knuckles in).
Once you’ve managed to create a soft, airy and extremely pliable dough, it’s time to start the stretching process and we can’t stress how important this stage is. Words alone cannot illustrate the difficult process of stretching so please study the hands of the pros – Youtube has a massive number of pizza dough stretching guides, as you'd expect. This is the one that came up top of the search results.
If you're looking for some top pizza dough recipes, Ooni's Recipe Page is a good place to start.
Making pizza at home: using pre-made dough
If I were you, I’d cut out the complicated and messy dough-making malarky and opt for pre-made pizza dough balls which you can buy both online and from some supermarkets. The act of making pizza dough is notoriously difficult and unless you really know what you’re doing, you simply won’t make a better dough ball than some of the producers highlighted below.
My favourite two choices of pre-produced dough balls are those made by Dough Dealers and Massarellas. Dough Dealers sources its products directly from established London pizza restaurants before shipping them in cooler bags – but only to addresses in London!
We received a package of soft Neapolitan-style dough balls, fresh passata, fresh Buffalo mozzarella and a flour and semolina mix (for laying out the dough), all pre-prepared by award-winning pizzeria L’oro di Napoli in Ealing. We put them in the excellent Sage The Smart Oven Pizzaiolo and they produced some of the most genuine restaurant-like pizzas this writer has ever tasted, with a deep, crispy, lightly salted crust replete with leopard spots and a perfectly browned base. Absolute magic!
If you live anywhere in the country other than the Scottish Highlands, Channel Islands, Isle of Man or Northern Ireland, then this pizza lover wholeheartedly recommends Massarellas, an artisan pizza dough manufacturer based in Yorkshire. They sent us two bags of balls – Classic and Sourdough – and they were both off the scale in terms of texture and flavour. The Sourdough version became an instant favourite simply because it ticked every single box of what a perfect pizza should be: a huge airy, almost hollow crust with leopard spots, a dark crispy base, light as a feather throughout and full of authentic Italian flavour. If you live in an area where Dough Dealers doesn’t operate (basically everywhere outside London), you likely won’t find better pizza balls than these. Order some now – I guarantee you will not be disappointed. Massarellas delivers its dough balls on a Friday so get your order in before 11am on the Wednesday.
Ooni Sourdough Dough Balls are my third favourite choice – light and pliable dough made from high quality ingredients, including organic Caputo Tipo 00 pizzeria flour, live yeast, purified water and Himalayan pink salt for extra pizzazz. Available in sealed individual packs of 24 and dispatched pronto when in stock, you simply freeze them on arrival and follow the included instructions when ready to bake. These balls are properly good.
Northern Dough dough balls are easiest to get hold of because you can buy them in pre-frozen pairs from Waitrose and other supermarkets. However, they're not as fresh tasting as those from Dough Dealers, Massarellas or Ooni – nor as salty – and you will almost certainly need to cut the dried crust off their tops or leave a damp tea towel on top for about an hour. If you don't, your pizza base (or top) will look like a map of the world and have the texture of cardboard.
Yes, you’ll still need to stretch these pre-made dough balls yourself – remember no rolling pins – but you’ll be saving a lot of extra hassle (and mess) by cutting out the prepping part.
What you’re looking for is an almost gossamer thin centre and about quarter to half an inch of crust that hasn’t been pinched into a peak. Indeed, the crust needs to be nicely rounded or the resulting pizza will just look rank and make everyone walk out, and go home disappointed.
Now you’ve sorted the dough, it’s time to think about toppings. Every pizza requires a thin film of tomato passata and one of our faves is Pizza Express tinned Passata, which includes basil and cracked black pepper. Mozzarella is not actually, strictly speaking, an essential ingredient but us Brits can't do without it – we’d recommend fresh buffalo mozzarella broken off into thumb sized chunks and sprinkled sparingly over the base. If you load too much on, it'll smother the base when baked and look more like a New York pizza slice (no bad thing). The extra weight may also make it more difficult to fling the base off the pizza peel (see below).
What you bung on next is down to personal taste but capers, anchovies, jalapeño peppers, Italian sausage of various kinds are all fine ingredients that give pizzas real zing. However, you could just use tomato sauce and a few fresh basil leaves. A pizza can be anything from a very light snack to a full-on meal, depending on how high you pile your toppings. If you want to be authentic about it, keep them to a minimum. If you showed a stuffed crust pizza loaded with sausage, ham, 15 cheeses, mushrooms, olives and pineapple to a Neopolitan, he would probably attempt to strangle you with it.
My final – vital – tip is to ensure that the pizza peel – the flat thing you use to 'stab' the pizza into the oven with – is coated in a good dusting of flour or the pizza base will not slide off the peel properly and you will have an absolute disaster on your hands. Seriously, the whole pizza will either crinkle up or, worse, fold over on itself. Your attempts to rectify the matter – while fighting against heat equivalent to the surface of the sun – will likely only make matters worse. Most first timers have learned that the hard way. So, remember, a good dusting of flour on the peel and a well-timed forward-backwards jab so the base slides off in one smooth move. Now go forth, mio amico, and bake.
Get a proper pizza oven
It just so happens, as I mentioned before, that T3 has a guide to the best pizza ovens, so do check that out.
Wood-fired, gas or electric you ask? As with the best barbecue grills, purists will tell you to do it as nature intended and get wood, while those in a hurry will say, use gas or electricity as it's quicker and more controllable. Most people won't be able to tell the difference anyway.
Keep your eye on the ball
The only caveat with baking pizzas using a dedicated oven is that you really need to keep a constant vigilance because with a properly heated pizza oven, it takes between 90 and 120 seconds to bake. Leave it for just a few seconds longer and you’ll be pulling out a blackened mass that resembles a council drain cover.
What should an authentic pizza look like? This is dangerous territory but everyone from Napoli we've met likes it not only thin and with quite minimal toppings but also decidedly scorched around the edges. They also want the crispy underneath to look brown-ish, dusty, indeed almost dirty.
Now you know the basic ins and outs of home pizza baking, why not dip in and take your pick from our lovingly curated list of top-quality domestic pizza ovens. Believe us, your friends will be round in a jiffy.