The Tanita BC-401 is one of Tanita's most affordable body composition monitor, yet it offers plenty of data to pore over in your spare time. Since measuring weight is not hip anymore in 2020, Tanita chose to market the BC-401 as a 'health-monitor' and not as bathroom scales. Either way, it will provide you with plenty of body metrics to work with, regardless of your fitness levels.
There are more advanced Tanita models on our best bathroom scales guide, like the Tanita RD-953 or the Tanita BC-1500 Ironman, both being feature-rich but also more expensive; in fact, the BC-1500 is over six-times more expensive as the BC-401. However, the Tanita BC-1500 is aimed at serious sportspeople, as opposed to the subject of this review, the Tanita BC-401, which offers reliable accuracy and a lot of features for less. Sort of.
- The rival: Gamin Index Smart Scale which works with the Garmin Connect app
- Best Fitbit: which Fitbit fitness tracker or smartwatch is best for you?
- Best running watch: the best fitness watches for running, gym, workouts, cycling and hiking
Tanita BC-401 body composition monitor review: design and ergonomics
I wouldn't call the Tanita BC-401 a good looking device, unlike the handsome (yet not-so-smart) Fitbit Aria Air. If anything, the Tanita BC-401 looks something from the noughties and hasn't really got any discernible features. It's just like the scales next door: grey-coloured slab with a glass top and a black bezel. You get the four connection boxes in the corner of the scales and four touch-buttons in the middle which you won't use often (measurements can initiated from the app).
The bottom cover is straight up black plastic, so are the legs, and even though the they can feel a bit flimsy, the Tanita BC-401 can support user weight up to 150 kg. My biggest issue with this particular body composition monitor was the depth of the platform: it's only 20 cm so people with shoe sizes larger than 6 might struggle to stand on it without their feet hanging off the platform.
- Get fit in 2020: these are the best exercises for beginners
- 5 reasons why you should start running and the best running gear you'll need
- How to lose belly fat: 6 easy ways to burn fat and reveal your abs in 2020
Tanita BC-401 body composition monitor review: the My Tanita app
Unlike the Fitbit Aria Air, the Tanita BC-401 body composition monitor can be used without the accompanying app. I would recommend using the My Tanita app nevertheless, because it is much easier to digest to information through the app, using the easy-to-read charts and histograms.
You can also initiate readings using the My Tanita app: place the Tanita BC-401 down on the floor, launch the app, tap on 'Measure' and then 'Start measurement'. The phone will then wake up the scale and within a couple of seconds, you can step on the scales.
The reading itself is done really quickly, it took 3-5 seconds each time for my stats to show up in the app after I stepped on the scales.
And there are plenty of stats being measured:
- Weight: I hope this doesn't need any further explanation.
- Body fat %: proportion of fat to the total body weight. Not many of us have to worry about being 'underfat' but if you are 'overfat' – even obese – you might want to try and get back into the green zone.
- Total body water %: the total amount of fluid in the body expressed as a percentage of total weight. I'm a big advocate of drinking loads of water – I tend to visit the loo once every other hour – so it was great to see that my water levels were on point. Always nice to get some reassurance!
- Muscle mass: predicted weight of all the muscles in your body. I wasn't expected this number to be so high, given I haven't got a muscular body but alas, apart from a stone and half of other stuff, I'm all muscle apparently.
- Physique rating: this metric assesses muscle and body fat levels and puts you in one of the nine body type categories. The Y-axis goes from lean to obese and the X-axis from low to high. Ideally you would like to be in the middle of chart and avoid the four corners.
- Bone mineral mass: this metric is called bone mass in the app and it predicts the weight of bone material in your body. Hopefully, you are not under- or over-bony. If you are the former, up your calcium intake. If the latter: not sure. 🤷
- Basal metabolic rate (BMR): this is also know as resting metabolic rate and it measures the amount of calories your body use without you doing anything. Want to lose weight? Go under. Gain? Go over.
- Metabolic age: compares your BMR to the average for your age group. If your metabolic age is higher than your actual age, that means your body is not in a good shape and you should start working on getting healthier. Like now.
- BMI: BMI is a general indicator of health at best times but in most cases, it's pretty pointless.
- Visceral fat: the amount of fat located around the vital organs. Middle-aged men tend to have loads of this and if you are one of those skinny blokes with a pot-belly, you probably have too much visceral fat.
All the different metrics are explained in the My Tanita app so even if half of the above list doesn't make much sense to you now, it will looking at the data and descriptions in the app. You can also check how the metrics changed over time and set goals for yourself in the app.
One issue with the My Tanita app is the lack of support for third-party apps. You can only sync the app with Google Fit/Apple Health, which is not much consolation if you have been logging your weight in other apps before. I would expect at least a MyFitnessPal integration, if nothing else.
You can sync your My Tanita data with Google Fit/Apple Health and then sync that with MyfitnessPal, but a more direct approach would work better I feel.
- Best Fitbit deals
- How to lose weight fast: 10 strategies for weight loss
- How to get a six pack: A six-pack of top tips plus the best abs exercises to tone up to a flat stomach
Tanita BC-401 body composition monitor review: verdict
For the price, the Tanita BC-401 body composition monitor offers a heap-load of data in an acceptable looking package. It might not be the most ergonomic scales on the world but it won't stop the Tanita BC-401 to do its jobs quickly and accurately.
Regarding accuracy, it's hard to tell how precise the Tanita BC-401 actually is but the weight reading is definitely not way off, compared to other scales. If you need to know for sure how heavy you actually are, get a commercial scale, like the Tanita MC-980 Uplus Multi Frequency Segmental Body Composition Analyser. For everybody else, the Tanita BC-401 will work just fine.
All readings from the body composition monitor are fed into the My Tanita app where you can follow the trend of each and every metric the Tanita BC-401 measures. There will be some types of data which won't change very often – like bone mass – but others will and if they do, you will know straight away by looking at the handy charts.
Cheap and cheerful it might be, the data monitored by Tanita BC-401 will be enough for most people. And if you have small feet, all the better.