Windows 8 review
Forget everything you know about Windows. While Apple's recent OS X Mountain Lion was a relatively simple polish of the Cupertino brand's OS, and even Windows 7 was largely Windows Vista with a few tweaks, Windows 8 is Microsoft's attempt to redefine the PC platform itself - not quite as a closed system like Xbox 360, but one it gets to control like never before.
We took a closer look at the Windows 8 Consumer preview...
Windows 8: Updates
The most obvious change is the new Metro interface which greets you instead of the standard desktop, and is made up of panes like Mail, People, Photos and Video to give you instant access to your most important files and information via slick full-screen applications.
You still have the classic Desktop view, which works much like Windows 7 did, but it feels like a poor cousin to the shiny Metro introduction, which was clearly designed around touch-screen controls rather than traditional PC interactions.
Likewise, where Metro apps get huge flashy colourful tiles, individual programs get tiny icons. It's not hard to see which interface has Microsoft's favour, even if the likes of Office are obviously going to live on the Desktop rather than in a tile.
Windows 8: Features
That's the core of Windows 8 right now - while Metro is a great concept for a touch device like the upcoming Microsoft Surface, and Windows 7 is a fantastic desktop OS, put together, they just don't get along. With Metro's prominence, that's a problem.
These include Twitter, Facebook and Flickr, but mostly revolve around Microsoft's own brand names and technologies. There's no dedicated Games tile for instance, or even Games For Windows. It's specifically 'Xbox LIVE Games'. Elsewhere, the "Videos" tile not only gives most of its screen priority to another marketplace, it shoe-horns in advert boxes. Rude.
Windows 8: Performance
On the desktop, things feel much the same as in Windows 7. Boot up times however are incredibly fast, and Metro apps spring into action instantly. They may be underpowered compared to dedicated desktop apps, but they're great at jumping straight into stuff you want - your mail, your photos, your videos, or whatever else.
On a touch screen system, or even as an alternate UI to bring up on command, Metro would be great. As the new face of your PC though, it can be incredibly obnoxious - and really gets in the way.
Windows 8: Verdict
If the preview version is anything to go by, Windows 8 feels like Microsoft giving itself a highly profitable gift rather than presenting the world with a great new OS. For touch devices, it's superb - slick, fast, beautiful. It's going to be a credit to Surface and a great platform for new apps.
Check out our Windows 8 tablet video:
Windows 8 review
Windows 8 reviewT3
When Microsoft changes Windows it sets the agenda for the next four years and with Windows 8 it means serious business
Windows 8 review
- Gorgeous new live interface
- Apps finally on Windows
- Great on older hardware
- The steep learning curve
- Fledgling app eco-system
- Clunky on traditional laptop
The lifespan of Windows 7 has seen the iPad, Android and smartphone transform the technology landscape, and for Microsoft, Windows 8 is the time to shine.
In a world where minor operating system updates come and go weekly, new versions of Windows are still global events. Like the World Cup, Microsoft has stuck to a four-year refresh cycle and when a new version is released, it sets the agenda.
Microsoft doesn’t make regular incremental updates, like we’re used to with OS X Mountain Lion, Android 4.0 Jelly Bean and iOS 6. Yes, the system is regularly maintained, as anyone who has turned on their PC to be confronted with 36 new updates and two reboots will atest, but these never come in the form of new features. When Microsoft changes its OS it doesn't mess around.
Windows 8: Updates
Underneath, Windows 8 closely resembles its older brother Windows 7, but it has been given a fine tuning, meaning that it will run just as well on equivalent hardware. Gone are the days of expensive upgrades for the latest version of Windows and Microsoft says that Windows 8 will run better on the same hardware as its predecessor.
The minimum spec required for Windows 8 is surprisingly low, with Microsoft stating that a 1 GHz dual-core processor, 2GB of RAM and a graphics card capable of DX9 is all that’s required. That puts any machine from the last 5 years in its sights, so there are no performance headaches for upgraders.
Microsoft has also changed its pricing significantly, and at £24.99 for an upgrade copy until January next year, Redmond is going all out for widespread adoption.
The most noticeable upgrade to Windows 8 is the Start screen, which has been given a radical rethink. The emergence of touchscreen has governed its design, so a brightly tiled interface dominates Windows 8.
It commands the entire Windows experience and takes the place of the old Start Menu, and the bottom left hand corner of the traditional desktop is now without that familiar round orb.
The new user is a rich HTML 5 experience at the heart of the traditional operating system, and it heralds a major change in PCs that has long been preserve of Microsoft’s competitors: apps.
A huge addition to Windows 8 is the Windows Store, its inaugural app area, which Redmond hopes will become as populous and vibrant as the Apple App Store and Google Play. At launch it is far from full, with a handful of big name apps such as Angry Birds Star Wars available to buy, but don’t expect a winter wonderland of incredible offerings this Christmas, as it’s going to take time to build.
The current crop of apps isn’t fantastic either. They are fast, slick and attractive, thanks to HTML 5 and there’s plenty of potential for some great functionality. However, with a few notable exceptions the launch line-up only offers basic functionality and dubious quality.
That’s not to say that Windows 8 hasn’t got the potential to play host to some fantastic apps but Microsoft needs to get developers on-board fast. The good news is that a predicted 300 million installs of Windows 8 by the end of 2013 means that it shouldn’t be hard to get the Windows Store thriving.
The final headline change to Windows 8 is the introduction of Windows 8 RT, the first version of the operating system to work on ARM-based processors. This means that Windows now has a home on tablets that can rival the iPad and Android army for size, weight battery life and power.
The general appearance of Windows RT is identical to its full-fat x86 cousins, but you won’t be able to run classic desktop applications from the internet.
That means that RT users are limited to running apps Windows Store. It’s has the potential to cause huge confusion, especially as devices like Microsoft Surface, Asus Vivo Tab and Samsung ATIVsmart PC are available in both x86 and RT flavours.
Windows 8: Interface
The biggest change to Windows 8 is the Start Screen interface. Like the old Start menu it shows you the apps and programs installed on your PC, but unlike the tiny menu tucked in the bottom corner of your desktop, the Start screen takes the whole screen.
It looks fantastic and works a treat, showing every app or program as a tile, which is easy for touch and mouse and keyboard alone. The tiles are also ‘live’ which means they turn and twist to show off information, such as new emails, photos, contacts, news headlines and even travel updates.
It’s a world away from the bland, static interface of Mac OS X Mountain Lion, or even the app focused iOS 6, and it’s truly refreshing to see your laptop or tablet alive with your personal information.
The problem is, however, that sometimes Windows doesn’t even know how to behave.
A case in point is when inserting a USB key. As soon as it’s plugged in you’re whisked to the old desktop, and when you double tap a picture, you go back to the new interface.
However, if you now want to add it to your pictures library, you’re heading back to the desktop again. It’s confusing, and it’s as if the old and new Windows are fighting against each other, and you’re only option is to adapt the way you work.
Windows 8 also connects with the cloud and Microsoft SkyDrive powers the back end. It’s been a mediocre service for a long time, but it does a great job of powering Windows 8, silently getting on with its job of storing files and information- although transfer speeds really need a shot in the arm.
While Start screen is a triumph of design it’s likely to be the biggest cause of disconcertion with Windows 8 from consumers. You’re forced to adopt it from the moment you boot to the time you shutdown.
Yes, you can drop back into classic desktop but to love Windows 8, hell, even use it effectively, you have to embrace the new interface 100%. The problem is that with a mouse and keyboard, that’s not an easy thing to do.
Windows 8 works wonderfully with the range of gestures with touchscreen devices and it’s one of the most complete and effortless operating systems to grace the tablet form. That’s a bold statement, but it’s easy to master and enables you to access what you need far more easily than any mobile OS.
The Charm bar, accessible from the right hand edge, enables you to search any part of Windows 8 from files, apps, settings, the Windows Store and even the internet. It ties the whole Windows 8 experience together and once you start using these new parts of the OS, things start to come together.
While this might be intuitive via touch taking to the mouse will even leave the most technically savvy user bemused. Like OS X, Windows 8 revolves around a series of hot corners, such as the bottom right for the Charm bar, which handles operating system wide searching, settings and sharing, and top left to see a list of open apps and windows.
It’s a steep learning curve and without migrating to touchscreen it’s never 100% comfortable.
Windows 8: Features
While the Windows Store is one of the biggest additions to the new OS, there are plenty of apps pre-installed, which bring tonnes of new features to Windows 8.
The most notable of these is the Xbox Video and Xbox Music apps, which as the name suggests, plugs into the already thriving ecosystems available on the console.
These apps provide a natural home for MP3, video and media stored on your PC or tablet, but they also you to buy and rent media from your PC. In fact, the Xbox Music Pass offers ad supported streaming of 30 million tracks, with a premium version allowing downloads on five devices available.
While we fear that few will be excited about these services with the prevalence of services such as Spotify, Netflix and Lovefilm (all of which are available in Windows 8), the apps are well built, full of content, and thankfully, Microsoft dropped its bizarre points payment system, to make Xbox Video and Music genuinely compelling.
Functionality is basic, when compared to the social sharing and playlist creating which is engrained in the likes of Spotify, however, it brings free, streamable music to the masses and we like it.
There’s also a modern user interface version of Internet Explorer 10 built into the start screen. It differs from the traditional Windows version, which is still accessible from the old desktop, by being touch-friendly, clear and vibrant. However, like many of the new apps we found it to be buggy, often not displaying web sites correctly, and rendering incoherently when scrolling through web sites.
Amusingly, the Modern UI version of Google Chrome is much better and shows what the slick new interface is capable of.
Windows 8: Performance
One of the most noticeable improvements in Windows 8 is its performance, and having tested the final build across a host of devices, including the Sony VAIO Duo 11, Asus Vivo Tab RT, the Samsung ATIVsmart PC, the Dell XPS 27 Touch and the Lenovo IdeaPad Yoga 13 and we haven’t found once noticed annoying glitches or drops in speed.
The Start screen is responsive and glides from side to side, with the animated gesture menus sliding from the left and right with iPad-like aplomb. Searches are performed almost instantaneously, and it’s obvious that Windows 8 is a finely tuned re-thinking of the classic Windows build.
Even Windows RT, the ARM based skew of the operating system for mobile processors, performed extremely well, and easily outscored the iPad 3 in Sun Spider benchmark tests and matching the iPhone 5 for raw browsing speed.
The most noticeable improvements have been around connected devices, and gone are the long, sluggish recognition of USB drives, external storage and peripherals. Connect a device by USB and it fires into life, and we enjoyed improved transfer speeds while copying files and folders.
Windows 8: Verdict
Windows 8 is a well rounded operating system that looks great, feels fresh, and most of all, really works. It’s hard to master and the Windows Store needs a serious shot in the arm over the coming months, but it’s a solid start and an enormous leap forward to Microsoft.
It’s clear that Windows 8 is an operating system that looks to the future, and still may be ahead of its time. While it’s a triumph on touch displays it’s hard to master on laptops and desktops and its biggest detractors will be those unwilling or unable to change the way they work. It’s truly a case of adapt or die.
Microsoft should be applauded for its brave and single-minded support for a touchscreen future. By pandering to the mouse and keyboard it would have castrated Windows 8’s effectiveness in the years ahead. It begs for manufacturers to build touchscreen devices, and now they must patiently wait for the world to catch up - and pray that it doesn't move on.
Windows 8 release date: 26 October 2012
Windows 8 price: £24.99 (Upgrade from an existing Windows product until 31 January 2013)
Windows 8 mixes desktop and touch devices into one operating system - but will Microsoft's attempt to beat Apple end up a pyrrhic victory?
Best Smartphones: Reviews
HTC One M8 review
The new HTC One (M8) is the brand's new flagship Android KitKat smartphone
Samsung Galaxy S5 review
Can the new Samsung Galaxy S5 flagship smartphone blow away the competition?
iPhone 5s review
After a year on sale, is Apple's 4-inch smartphone still the one to buy?
Google Nexus 5 review
Can the Google Nexus 5 trump the excellent Nexus 4?
LG G2 review
Is the G2 the best Android smartphone around?
HTC One Mini review
The HTC One Mini is a scaled down version of the popular HTC One Android phone
LG G Flex review
The LG G Flex is the maker's very first curved Android smartphone
Motorola Moto E review: Hands-on
Is the Motorola Moto E the best budget smartphone around?